"Well if I go down, I'm taking you with me." "Yeah? Well, if you do take me with you, I'm gonna sit in the back and complain the whole way and keep asking you if we're there yet."
Before we discuss anything else, I think it's something incredibly important to address how misleading they are, because all they've done is cause mismatched expectations to emerge, and in this instance, they've helped sink this episode's reception to some extent. And I understand why: it advertises Penny playing a larger role on the front box, but her character is only utilized as much as necessary (that is to say for roughly five seconds of screentime). Even if it's difficult, I don't think we can hold this episode's disregard for the character against it: that was never the direction the show was trying to take.
There's a lot to be said about how Penny just isn't on the writers' minds, and that's a problem in and of itself for sure. But we can't chalk this as a failure merely because some idiot watched two minutes of the episode, assumed it was going to do something else, and haphazardly wrote a rough description. Simply put, you can't evaluate an episode on the basis of that which it wasn't trying to do.
With that being said, though, "The Pact" certainly wasn't anything special, and though it was far from an abject failure, it came across as a rather scattershot effort. Let's chalk it under that "pleasant but forgettable" category.










